Where I Weigh In On the Cincinnati Zoo Tragedy

harambe.jpg
Harambe

I assume, unless you live under a rock, that you’ve heard about the recent gorilla tragedy at the Cincinnati Zoo last weekend. The one where authorities shot a 450-pound endangered gorilla named Harambe who was dragging around a four-year-boy who had crawled into the gorilla exhibit.

Because tranquilizers would’ve taken too long to ensure the child’s safety, zoo officials killed the beloved gorilla.

The incident was very sad and many are downright angry about it. Some believe the child was in no danger (Jane Goodall claims the gorilla was protecting the kid) while others think the boy’s mother should be held criminally responsible (an online “Justice for Harambe” petition received over 100,000 signatures in under 48 hours).

Maybe it’s because everyone’s been talking about it lately, including my blogging buddy over at Midlife Margaritas, but I’d like to throw in my perspective as well.

Now, you’re probably assuming that because I’m a mom of two kids that writes a mommy blog, I’m about to defend the mom…

And you’d be right. Let me tell you why.

People who have never had children don’t really understand what parenting is like. There’s nothing wrong with that, because how could they? You may be extremely intelligent and have a great imagination, but until you’ve actually experienced something, you can’t truly know how it feels.

As a parent who was once a non-parent, I can tell you a few things about having kids that become crystal clear after you’ve made the jump:

  1.  Parenting is extremely difficult. Every kid is different, but they’re all irrational
  2. You have to make a billion choices, all the time, about how to best handle your reckless, irrational kids
  3. Every single choice you make is wrong, according to someone

It starts before the kid even leaves your body. What are you eating during your pregnancy? Will you breastfeed (and subject everyone to obscenity) or use formula (and pump your kid full of chemicals)? Will you return to work (selfish) or stay at home (lazy)?

And it continues with your newborn (sleep training or cry-it-out?) and straight into toddler discipline. There’s someone out there claiming every method will scar your kids for life: spanking is physically abusive, raising your voice is emotionally abusive, and time-outs create fear of abandonment…

Yet if your kids act up, you’re clearly a negligent parent who needs to control them better.

It’s like we have these TV sitcom-induced fantasies about how reasonable kids would be if we just said the right things to them while playing relaxing music, but it doesn’t really work out that way.

Trust me, parents believe it’s a good idea to keep an eye on their kids, but it’s MUCH harder than it sounds. Kids are quick, curious, and mostly oblivious to the consequences of their actions. You watch them 24/7 while needing to do a bunch of other things too, like eat, sleep, pee, and sneeze.

It’s a rare parent who’s never lost sight of their kids for a second. You’d have to live in complete lockdown mode, never leaving the house unless your children are kept on leashes. And for every parent keeping his kids on leashes, there are hundreds of angry people thinking he’s humiliating them by treating them like animals.

One time, when Brontë was almost two, she ran out of the park and into the street.

She just stopped whatever she was doing and bolted, without warning. We screamed for her to stop, but she wouldn’t listen. I chased her, sobbing, while I was very pregnant and couldn’t reach her. We heard cars screeching mere moments before John finally caught up to her and made her stop.

It was terrifying. All we could picture was what would’ve happened if those cars hadn’t stopped. Brontë was testing her limits in those days and had no sense of what the real consequences might be. We did.

Luckily, everything was fine, but what if it weren’t? We would’ve been negligent. We would’ve been called unfit parents who should have their kids taken away.

The Cincinnati incident didn’t turn out so well. The family was unlucky… a mother lost sight of her tiny child for a moment, like nearly every parent has done.

Only she wasn’t as lucky as the rest of us.

harambe2.pngOF COURSE, they had to shoot the gorilla. Maybe Harambe wouldn’t have hurt the child, but we can’t know that. We couldn’t have been sure. A lowland silverback gorilla can crush a coconut one-handed… that innocent child’s brains could’ve been splattered in seconds, and we can’t take that kind of risk.

The fact that it was a young child only makes it more critical, but I’d feel the same way if a grown adult had accidentally fallen into the enclosure.

I love animals and think we should spare them as much discomfort as possible, but when push comes to shove, we have to choose human life. If I’m ever in a survival starvation situation involving people and animals, I don’t want the animals drawing equal straws with everyone else.

Because it was so tragic, I think people need someone to blame. They want, for example, to hold the family financially liable for the cost of the gorilla.

But they aren’t considering the consequences. If we made families liable, then parents could never take their children to the zoo, or anywhere, because they couldn’t afford the possibility that something bad might happen. Everyone would grow up under house arrest, never learning, exploring, or facing the consequences of anything.

Unfortunately, bad things are going to happen. Life is unpredictable and sometimes the planets line up in just the wrong way. I think it’s extremely sad that Harambe had to be put down last weekend, but don’t think scapegoating the parents will help.

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Where I Weigh In On the Cincinnati Zoo Tragedy”

  1. I’m totally with you on the parenting thing – even with other parents you can do no right and everyone’s an expert it seems. But the truth is as you say that children are irrational and reactive and at time uncontrollable despite our best will. Sometimes things go wrong, it’s not a perfect world.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. You’re right… I targeted non-parents in this piece because I’ve been hearing anti-kid stuff from some of them lately, but other parents can be just as bad.

      There’s never a perfect balance. People either think you’re negligent or overprotective–the “helicopter parent” phenomenon.

      And sometimes tragedies are just going to happen. Hindsight is 20/20 but all we can do in real life is our best.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks! Your post inspired me in the first place (along with all the comments and social media opinions I’ve read since then).

      That poor family. It really sounds like a witch hunt. I really think this could’ve happened to any parent of small children, unless they’re blessed with unusually docile kids.

      I’m sure the family feels horrible as it is.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s crazy to me that so many of the people who are calling for the parents’ punishment are actually parents themselves. Or at least that’s how it seems on my Facebook page. Maybe the idea of their own child getting hurt is so horrible, they have to separate themselves from it by pretending there’s no way it ever could have happened to them.

    I was definitely wishing that they could have tranquilized him – until I read an article that explained why this would’ve been the wrong move. Harambe could have fallen on the boy when losing consciousness, for example. It’s just an all around sad situation.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You know, you’re right… I started scanning comments sections and there ARE a lot of parents blaming the mom.

      I guess I assumed this would be mostly a non-parent perspective because it’s tough to understand how easily kids slip away until you’ve been there yourself. So many of us thought we would never do “X” as parents and found X happening anyway…

      I think you’re right about parents wanting to believe they would be in control of the situation. Any time tragedies happen, people try to find the guilty party, the mistake that led to it. It must be an attempt to feel safe, protected from these things because you’d know better.

      It’s all around a terrible event. One of those times they had to make the rough call because of the risks involved. I wish things could’ve worked out differently too.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s